39-71-706, MCA

MONTANA SUPREME COURT DECISIONS

[1983] Burglund v. Liberty Mutual Fire Ins. Co., 179 Mont. 298, 927 P.2d 1006 (1996) Commonly referenced as "indemnity benefits," benefits available under sections 39-71-705 through -708, MCA (1983) are based on the schedule of injuries set forth in section 39-71-705, MCA (1983). In this case, the back injury is a non-scheduled injury, which allows a maximum of 500 weeks of benefits. To determine an indemnity claim, the Court must consider the claimant's age, education, work experience, pain and disability, actual wage loss, and loss of future earning capacity. Although the WCC did not credit claimant's claims of current physical restrictions, that does not mean he will not suffer a possible loss of future earning capacity as a result of his injury. The Court's award of twenty percent, translating into 100 weeks of benefits, is supported by the record.

 
WORKERS' COMPENSATION COURT DECISIONS

[1995] Baumgartner v. Liberty NW [4/14/97] 1997 MTWCC 19 (WCC No. 9611-7642) Although it would take little more than three years for occupational disease claimant's wage loss to reach $10,000, meaning he would ordinarily qualify for the maximum indemnity award under section 39-72-405, MCA (1995), the Court applied the apportionment provisions of section 39-71-706, MCA (1995) to an award under section 405. Where medical evidence attributed only 60% of the causation of claimant's low back condition to work, he was awarded $6,000.

Burgan v. Nationwide Ins. Co. [10/04/95] 1995 MTWCC 75 The permanent partial disability benefits available under sections 39-71-705 through -708, MCA (1985), commonly referenced as “indemnity benefits,” seek to indemnify the injured worker for “possible” loss of future earning capacity, rather than any “actual” loss of earning capacity. These benefits are based on a schedule of injuries, but in the case of a non-scheduled injury, such as the back injury at issue here, the maximum number of weeks of benefits is 500 weeks, with the award for less than a total loss to “be proportionate to loss or loss of use.” §39-71-706(1), MCA (1985). In determining disability, the Court must consider the claimant’s age, education, work experience, pain and disability, actual wage loss, and possible loss of future earning capacity.

[1983] Burglund v. Liberty Mutual Northwest Ins. Co. [4/10/95] 1995 MTWCC 25A UPS driver is entitled to benefits under sections 39-71-705 through -708, MCA (1983) where those benefits are to indemnify the worker for "possible" loss of future earning capacity. "Indemnity benefits" under those statutes are based on a schedule of injuries set forth in section 39-71-705, MCA (1983). In the case of a non-scheduled injury, such as claimant's back condition the maximum number of weeks of benefits is 500. With reference to the statute's purpose of providing benefits in proportion to the loss, and the factors for consideration (age, education, work experience, pain and disability, actual wage loss, possible loss of future earning capacity), the Court finds an additional ten percent appropriate, which amounts to a total of twenty percent given the ten percent award for impairment already paid. [Note: the WCC was affirmed by the Supreme Court in Burglund v. Liberty Mutual Fire Ins. Co., 179 Mont. 298, 927 P.2d 1006 (1996).]